If the Yankees are forced to trade why not rent Carlos If the Yankees are forced to trade why not rent Carlos If the Yankees are forced to trade why not rent Carlos

If the Yankees are forced to trade why not rent Carlos

Carlos Quentin

Carlos Quentin (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The New York Yankees are rolling.

Winning their fifth game in a row by beating the Braves for the second night with a score of 6-4.

Skipper Joe Girardi and crew deserve the recognition here for guiding this team through all the adversity and injuries.

So now that we all know the Yankees can still win, what will GM Brian Cashman due to insure this team gets to October?

With an already lengthy DL list and some players past their primes, Cashman will be looking to add something to assure the Yankees have the smoothest ride into the postseason.

Now how big Cashman will go weighs heavily on the outcome of Brett Gardner’s elbow diagnosis, which has sidelined him since April 17th. Gardner has made it all the way to a minor league start in his rehab three times; and all three times have led to a setback.

This week Gardner has already seen Dr. James Andrews and is on his way to see the Reds orthopedic Dr. Timothy Kremchek in Cincinnati today.

Gardner’s elbow injury has been grim so far with all the setbacks and multiple doctor visits is never a good sign.

So, the worst-case scenario is Gardner is out for the season, and that is when things get complicated.

1) Does Cashman make a trade for an everyday outfielder?

2) Or do the Yankees keep platooning Raul Ibanez, Dewayne Wise, Jayson Nix and Andruw Jones in left field for the rest of the season, praying that no one gets injured?

According to Marc Craig of the Star-Ledger, Cashman had this to say, “Our guys are doing a great job despite not having him here. But I don’t want to overexpose the old guys out there and run them out there every day,” which makes me to believe the Yankees will be taking the trade route sans Gardner.

So, who would be a prime target for the Cashman?

One of the best outfielders rumored to be on the block is San Diego Padres Carlos Quentin.

Quentin is coming off a knee injury from last season, and has only recently returned less than two weeks ago. In the 11 games he is started, Quentin is posting a .455 batting average, with 15 hits, five homers, nine RBIs, three walks in 33 at-bats.

Those numbers are even more impactful when you realize he plays in Petco Park, which is about the most pitcher friendly stadium in the majors but overall it is still too small sample size to make a decision on.

If Quentin keeps up that rate, which would be God-like, his trade value could skyrocket.

Still, the Padres are getting new ownership come August so it is easy to presume there will be urgency in trading him and that could impact Quentin’s price tag.

The Padres have Quentin on a one-year,  $7+ million dollar deal so he is a free agent at the end of the season. That makes him a nice three-month rental worth giving up one good prospect or two decent prospects.

Now Quentin is on the later side of 29-years old; he played for the Chicago White Sox from 2009-2012, so he is quite familiar with playing in the AL already.

If rumors are true all five AL East teams, his old team the White Sox, along with the Tigers, Mets, Braves and the sleeper being the Pirates are all keeping tabs on Quentin, but he has to stay healthy through mid-July or the Padres will forced to keep him.

Whether this trade is even a viable option regardless of what happens with Gardner is up in the air. This is mainly because other teams tend to get jack-up prices when dealing with the Yanks, which is expected but whether the farm system can afford it is another thing.

Also note that I am NOT suggesting Quentin as Nick Swisher’s future replacement in 2013, but to take Gardner’s temporarily for the rest of 2012 I most certainly am.

The Yankees are not even atop the Quentin-rumors yet, but when Gardner’s results come back on his elbow that could all change in a snap.

Following last night’s win in Atlanta, Gardner made a surprise visit to his teammates in the clubhouse; and Newsday’s Erik Boland reported that Gardner stated that he believes he will play again this season.

Well I guess all Yankee fans can do is hope he is right, but I wouldn’t hold your breath.

Enhanced by Zemanta


  1. Richard Griffith says:

    Can you show me some stats that show Quentin is a good outfielder? I sure can't. Your article is mostly about defense and not running 40 y/o's out there to often, right?

  2. Richard Griffith says:

    His offensive numbers are similar to Swisher's. But he's coming off knee surgery so WHY would I put him in Left Field? Oh, right to spell a 10 time GG Andruw Jones/Ibanez.

    I think the DH job is pretty much taken.

  3. Tanned Tom says:

    Not in favor of trading for another guy who can barely field. Isn't that the problem with Ibanez and Jones? Gardner's injury points out how foolish it is to have a 4th and 5th OF who are too fragile to play in the field regularly. Jones has bum knees and can't hit lefties anymore, Ibanez is a complete joke in the OF – I've seen kitchen appliances with more range.
    I'd rather see the team try Dickerson and Mustelier in LF, or even Jack Cust.

  4. BigDawgDeeg says:

    Cashman better really think hard before he gets rid of Nick Swisher. This is a guy that will probably take alittle less to stay with the Yankees and Love being there or he will become a star for Tampa Bay Rays and insult Cashman by beating up on the Yankees every chance he gets.

    • Richard Griffith says:

      I agree but much more likely to go to Red Sox – someone who can afford him!!!