MLB Hot Stove: Carl Pavano to the New York Yankees Only If He Pays - Lady Loves Pinstripes MLB Hot Stove: Carl Pavano to the New York Yankees Only If He Pays - Lady Loves Pinstripes MLB Hot Stove: Carl Pavano to the New York Yankees Only If He Pays - Lady Loves Pinstripes

MLB Hot Stove: Carl Pavano to the New York Yankees Only If He Pays

This player’s name is the last one any New York Yankee player or fan wants to hear: Carl Pavano, also known in the Bronx as the “American Idle.”

Let me put it this way, for those of you who thought Javier Vazquez was disliked in the Bronx, Pavano makes Vazquez the Yankees prom-king.

Truth remains that Pavano is the next free agent considered to be worthwhile behind Cliff Lee, for at least 29 MLB teams.

Here is my warning…PROCEED WITH CAUTION.

Most Yankees fans never saw Pavano on the mound. That is because he only pitched 26 games, with injuries all the way from his shoulder to his buttocks. Pavano had record of 9-8 while in pinstripes, so his option for a fourth year was never going to happen.

Pavano’s three years in the Yankees rotation turned into more like $39.95 million vacation.

Pavano left New York with the impression of a slacker, as ironically the minute he was out of Yankees uniform he preformed well again and injury-free.

In 2009, Pavano made 33 starts, 21 games as a Cleveland Indiana and 12 as a Minnesota Twin. Pavano threw 200 innings in total, 50 more innings than his three-year total in the Bronx. Pavano threw one shutout and one complete game in 2009, to go along with his 147 strikeouts.

To go from zero to hero in one offseason is all the proof that was needed.

This past season Pavano was the Twins ace, finishing with a 17-11 record, over 221 innings, striking out 117 batters and an ERA of 3.75. He spent a total of zero days on the DL for the second season in a row. Pavano also was named the Twins pitcher of the year for 2010.

Nothing is more cowardly than not trying, taking the easy way out. Pavano might be a rich man, but one who can’t walk around publicly in New York City. At least I would not advise it, nor would he want to run into me.

Whether or not Pavano says his elbow, shoulder, knee, ribs and ass injuries were all real became irrelevant by his actions. They told another story, of a pitcher Yankee fans never knew, and it happened in too short a time considering the extent of this man’s injuries.

Hopefully, Pavano is a changed athlete because of the weak market sans Lee he is sure to go for a much higher price in this offseason market.

At least I know one fact, Carl Pavano won’t be an overpaid Yankee and that is a sentence  rarely said about any player and the Bronx Bombers.

More of a reason—Yankees better offer Cliff Lee the moon, sun and Pavano’s ass to get him in pinstripes.

GM Brain Cashman says the Yankees don’t need Lee. I agree, it’s much more desperate than that, the Yankees will bleed Lee if necessary.

  • Playoff Pavano nothing like NY bust (
  • Twins’ Pavano in position to send Yankees to early exit (
  • New York Yankees-Minnesota Twins ALDS Series Breakdown, Part 2 (
  • MLB Hot Stove: Separating New York Yankees Fact from Fiction (
  • New York Yankees-Minnesota Twins: ALDS Series Breakdown, Part Three (


  1. Uncle Mike says:

    I still don't think Cliff Lee is all that good. He's 26-22 over the last 2 regular seasons, and the Giants proved that he's not Sandy Koufax in the postseason, either. Like Apollo Creed's trainer told Rocky in the fight with Drago: "He's NOT a machine! He's a MAN!" As Yankee Fan Franklin Delano Roosevelt (well, he was there in '32 when Babe Ruth called his shot at Wrigley) said, "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself!" We don't need no stinkin' Cliff Lee, we just need to hit him!

    Speaking of guys I'd like to hit, and I don't mean their pitches, the ONLY way Carl Pavano ever gets into Yankee Stadium again is by buying a ticket! God knows he's got enough money for it!

    • Kate says:

      Oh I disagree, I think Lee is that good and he has done it at Yankee stadium.

      Also, having CC as his teammate again would benefit both guys….and Burnett and Lee are good'ol boys from Arkansas, so they are really close friends as well. AJ could use the guidance, like he had from Halladay from Lee.

      I agree that he is 32 years old, with back issues in the past…so contract-wise 4-years would be ideal with a fifth year option. That is not going to happen but maybe 5-years with a sixth year option with same paycheck as CC. I do not think 7-years is a good idea but if it makes the difference of Lee coming to NY than give him the years.

  2. […] Home › MLB › MLB Hot Stove: Carl Pavano to the New York Yankees Only If He Pays […]

  3. […] MLB Hot Stove: Carl Pavano to the New York Yankees Only If He Pays ( […]